Two U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) attorneys are facing potential disciplinary action after internal investigations found that their use of artificial intelligence violated professional conduct standards. The findings have intensified concerns over accuracy, confidentiality, and ethical responsibilities associated with AI in the American legal system.
The Justice Department’s Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) released two investigative summaries, detailing separate incidents involving fabricated legal material and unauthorized disclosure of confidential government documents. Both cases were referred to the department’s Professional Misconduct Review Unit for further consideration.
DOJ Lawyer Submitted Fabricated Legal Information
In the first case, an assistant U.S. attorney submitted a court filing containing fabricated quotations and inaccurate descriptions of previous judicial decisions.
When the court requested an explanation, the attorney attributed the mistakes to the accidental submission of a draft document rather than acknowledging that artificial intelligence had contributed to the inaccuracies.
During a subsequent hearing, the lawyer provided misleading information about the use of generative AI in preparing the legal filing. The OPR concluded that the attorney deliberately breached professional obligations concerning honesty and transparency before the court.
The incident highlights the dangers of AI hallucinations, where artificial intelligence systems generate convincing but inaccurate information, including nonexistent legal references and quotations.
Second DOJ Lawyer Violated Confidentiality Requirements
The second investigation involved a government attorney who uploaded restricted documents to an unauthorized public AI platform. Investigators discovered that two documents were subject to a protective order. Additional material contained sensitive personal and medical information relating to Justice Department employees.
The OPR determined that the attorney had recklessly disregarded departmental AI policies while knowingly violating confidentiality requirements and a tribunal’s protective order.
The incident demonstrates the security risks associated with entering sensitive legal information into AI systems without appropriate authorization or safeguards.
However, the published findings did not establish whether unauthorized individuals subsequently accessed the information.
What Legal Ethics Rules Apply to Artificial Intelligence?
The cases reinforce the importance of existing professional conduct standards, regardless of the technology lawyers use. In July 2024, the American Bar Association issued Formal Opinion 512, outlining ethical responsibilities associated with generative AI in legal practice.
These responsibilities include:
- Verifying AI-generated legal information before submitting court documents.
- Protecting confidential client and government information.
- Maintaining honesty when communicating with judges.
- Understanding the limitations and risks of AI tools.
- Properly supervising AI-assisted legal work.
Although professional conduct requirements vary by jurisdiction, attorneys remain responsible for the accuracy and integrity of their work.
What Happens Next to the DOJ Lawyers?
Both misconduct findings have been referred to the Professional Misconduct Review Unit, which evaluates appropriate disciplinary responses. Depending on the circumstances and applicable professional rules, attorney misconduct can result in reprimands, employment-related consequences, or referral to state bar authorities for additional disciplinary proceedings.
The published Justice Department summaries did not identify the attorneys or the AI platforms involved. Their current employment status and any final disciplinary penalties were not disclosed in the Reuters report published on November 18.
Growing Concerns Over AI in the US Legal System
Artificial intelligence is increasingly used for legal research, document preparation, contract analysis, and administrative work. However, these investigations illustrate how inadequate human oversight can undermine judicial proceedings and compromise sensitive information.
The two cases also demonstrate different types of professional risk. One concerns the reliability of information presented to a court, while the other involves restrictions on sharing confidential material.
The DOJ lawyers’ AI misconduct cases could encourage government agencies and private law firms to strengthen internal AI policies, verification procedures, and employee training.
As artificial intelligence becomes more integrated into legal practice, maintaining professional accountability remains essential. The latest investigations underline a fundamental principle: technology may assist attorneys, but responsibility for their legal work ultimately remains with the individuals who perform it.

